A Reflection on
the 2nd Sunday of Great Lent,
Sunday of St.
Gregory Palamas
Uncreated Light,
Uncreated Grace
Think of how often the Bible speaks about
light. Here is one of many key biblical passages:
Brethren, it is
the God who said, “Let light shine out of darkness,” who has shone in our
hearts to give the light of the knowledge of the glory of God in the face of
Christ. But we have this treasure in earthen vessels, to show that the
transcendent power belongs to God and not to us (2 Cor. 4:6-7)
We Orthodox believe that God’s uncreated grace sustains all of creation. It is
deep in all life— “everywhere present, filling all things”, as we say in our Prayer to the Holy Spirit. It is that “treasure in earthen vessels”, and it is manifested as light, “the light that shines out of darkness”—the light of God’s glory. We say that it is the same light revealed to the Apostles Peter, James, and John at Christ’s Transfiguration on Mount Tabor. Being the grace of God, it
is uncreated, which is to say that it is divine—and it is transformative, having power to transfigure us—power to make us like God, power to deify us. It is why Christ revealed Himself to Peter, James, and John in this glorious light—to make His light manifest and to fulfill the prophecy of Psalm 36:9, “For with Thee is the fountain of life, and in Thy light we see light”.
In fact, it is why God became Man—to illumine us and to give us life, to teach us and to transform us—to make us gods by grace.
On the 2nd Sunday of Great Lent, we remember Saint Gregory Palamas, because he defended the ancient Christian theology of deifying grace, divine light. He did so during what is called the Hesychast Controversy of the 14th century. And many say that it was at this time that a
serious break in ways of understanding grace became apparent to Christians of the East and the West.
The Hesychast
Controversy
Saint Gregory came to the defense of a group of monks on Mount Athos called “hesychasts” (the term having been derived from the word hesychia, meaning “stillness, quiet, rest, silence”). These monks sought God in the silence of fasting and prayer of the heart. But like other pious believers
since Saint Moses “the God-Seer” and Saints Peter, James, and John, these monks were blessed to see the uncreated grace or glory of God in divine, uncreated light—God deemed them worthy to take that light into themselves briefly, and so they were enabled to see the uncreated light. For, as the Fathers say, one cannot see this light with our physical eyes unless that light is in us.
The Hesychast Controversy concerned the significance of this light revealed to these monks. Saint Gregory’s disputants Barlaam of Calabria and Gregory Akindynos, considered this a “phantom light”—that is to say, a psychological phenomenon, something created—while this saint affirmed that it was indeed uncreated grace, the very same, uncreated light revealed to St. Moses in the Burning Bush on Mount Horeb and the Apostles on Mount Tabor.
Central to this controversy was the question, How can we know God? Barlaam maintained that it was through philosophy, critical thinking, and rational discourse, while St. Gregory insisted that it was through prayer of the heart and true Orthodox worship.
The Natural Symbol
With close reference to the Greek and Syriac Church Fathers of the 1st millennium who had a way of understanding grace derived from both Testaments of Holy Scripture, Gregory Palamas distinguished what he called “a natural symbol” from other kinds of symbols. Unlike an ordinary symbol which is merely a sign—as the American flag signifies our nation or golden arches signify McDonald hamburgers and fries—a natural symbol is naturally connected to that which it signifies in a way that a flag or those golden arches are not naturally connected to what they signify. In his Triads, Gregory gives this example: “When the sun is about to come up, the dawn is a natural symbol of its light, and the heat is a natural symbol of the burning power of fire…Therefore, the natural symbol always coexists with the nature from which it has its being, since it is a natural symbol of that nature”. He then brings forward a passage from Saint John Damascene’s Homily on the Transfiguration, where the light of Christ’s Transfiguration on Mount Tabor is received as a symbol in the same sense—for it is not “‘a phantom’…for He (Christ) IS the true light, the adornment of glory’”. In other words, God is one with His light. He is one with His glory.
His glory is uncreated grace. It is divine.
It is God.
And whoever sees the uncreated light sees God.
“The Light of
Christ Illumines All!”
But the uncreated light of Christ illumines all of mankind—that is, all who seek true knowledge of God through prayer of the heart, humility, and love. For it is a cleansing light; it is a purifying light; it is “the light of the knowledge of the glory of God in the face of Christ”, as Saint Paul says. It is the light that deifies us, as we work with God toward our salvation “with fear and trembling” (cf. Phil. 2:12-13). Some struggle ceaselessly, devoting their lives to prayer and fasting. Scaling that mountain with Saint Moses and the three Apostles, on rare occasions they may be blessed
to see the uncreated light of grace with their physical eyes transformed by that light. Then that light begins to abide in them. But the rest of us at the foot of that mountain looking up are given cleansing knowledge of this grace, for we are given to see in faith.
The Fathers call this noetic vision, seeing with the eye of our heart. And learning to see this way marks the beginning of our own deification.
Deification: Our
Union with God
Saint Gregory summarized the understanding of the Holy Fathers regarding the Incarnation. Jesus Christ is fully God and fully Man. He is that unique Person who is both God by nature and Man by nature. This means that His humanity is in His divinity and His divinity is in His humanity, unmixed, unchanged, without separation, and without division. The Church Fathers call this the mystery of the hypostatic union.
On the other hand, we are human beings by nature. We cannot become divine by nature. But as we partake of Christ’s Body and Blood — His deified humanity — we receive uncreated grace through the Holy Spirit. This means that our union with God can only be by uncreated grace—that very same light revealed to Moses in the Burning Bush and the Apostles at the Transfiguration of Christ.
Remembering Saint
Gregory
This is why the Church honors Gregory Palamas on the 2nd Sunday of Great Lent. It is to remind us of the power of uncreated, divine grace to cleanse, illuminate, and deify us as we strive to see God with greater clarity—repenting, praying, fasting, giving alms, worshipping God, and receiving Holy Communion in joyful anticipation of our own resurrection, when we shall be one with the light of Christ—that is, transfigured, deified—when we shall see Him as He is, face to face (cf.
1 John 3:2; 1 Cor. 13:12; Rev. 22:4), when we shall see Him within ourselves and each other in the fullness of God’s Kingdom.
Conclusion
Few of us are blessed to see the light of divine, uncreated grace with our physical eyes, but as we strive to live faithfully in God’s grace, we come to know God in our hearts—and this is a kind of seeing, a kind of knowledge, a kind of in-sight. Especially on this 2nd Sunday of Great
Lent, we affirm the ancient, Orthodox Christian understanding of divine grace as set forth by the Holy Fathers and finally as articulated by Saint Gregory during the Hesychast Controversy. But we celebrate our having been given divine in-sight every time we come together as the Body of Christ.
It is what we proclaim on receiving Christ’s Body and Blood every Sunday at every Divine Liturgy:
We have seen the True Light! We have received the Heavenly Spirit! We have found the True Faith! Worshiping the Undivided Trinity, Who has saved us.